What does the Crypto Community Want? Cryptocurrencies as Securities or Commodities

September 5, 2022
Knowledge Center » Blog » What does the Crypto Community Want? Cryptocurrencies as Securities or Commodities

The crypto community is currently divided on what they want cryptocurrencies to be classified as - securities or commodities. How will this classification impact the future of cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology? There are benefits and drawbacks to classifying cryptocurrencies as securities or commodities. This decision will affect everyday investors and businesses who use cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology. Let's take a closer look at how this debate is playing out.

What does the crypto community want?

Cryptocurrencies are still a relatively new phenomenon in the span of the larger financial sector, and their classification is still up for debate. Some people believe that they should be classified as securities, while others argue that they should be considered commodities.

The main argument for classifying cryptocurrencies as securities are that they are essential investments, and investors expect to make a return on their investment. This is similar to how traditional stocks and bonds are classified. Additionally, many Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs) have been structured in a way that resembles traditional IPOs, which further strengthens the case for classifying cryptocurrencies as securities.

The main argument for classifying cryptocurrencies as commodities are that they are not regulated by governments or financial institutions. This means that they can be used in a variety of ways, including as a currency or investment vehicle. Additionally, the value of cryptocurrencies is not based on the performance of any particular company or asset, but rather on the overall demand for them.

There is no right or wrong answer when it comes to classifying cryptocurrencies – It will ultimately depend on how the courts and regulatory bodies decide to classify them. However, it is important to understand the differences between these two classifications so that you can make informed decisions about investing in them.

What are the benefits and drawbacks?

Cryptocurrencies offer investors a new way to invest in the market and because they are decentralized, they offer a new level of security that traditional securities do not. Their popularity has caused them to be classified as securities by some, but others believe that their unique nature should classify them as commodities. The benefits of classifying cryptocurrencies as securities would be that they would be regulated by the SEC or other governing body and would have to meet certain requirements in order to be traded. This would give investors confidence that the companies behind these cryptocurrencies are legitimate and that their investments are protected. The drawbacks of classifying cryptocurrencies as securities would be that this could stifle innovation in the industry, as companies would have to meet more rigorous requirements in order to launch their coins. Additionally, it could lead to more scrutiny from regulators, which could slow down the growth of the industry.

On the other side, the benefits of classifying cryptocurrencies as commodities would be that they would not be regulated as heavily as securities, which could allow for more innovation in the industry. Additionally, because they would not fall under the jurisdiction of the SEC, they would be less likely to experience scrutiny from regulators, which could speed up their growth. The drawbacks of classifying cryptocurrencies as commodities are that they would not be protected by the same regulations as securities, which could lead to investors being taken advantage of. Additionally, because commodities are not as tightly regulated as securities, it could be more difficult for investors to get accurate information about these investments.

These benefits and drawbacks are presented at a very high level, however, and it's important to note that at the end of the day, regulation and specific classification of cryptocurrencies is likely to come at the hand of the SEC, the IRS, and other governing bodies - at least in the US.

How will this decision affect everyday investors and businesses?

Cryptocurrencies being classified as commodities or securities will have different effects on everyday investors and businesses who use cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology.

For everyday investors, the classification of cryptocurrencies as commodities or securities will not have a significant impact. The value of cryptocurrencies will continue to be determined by supply and demand, and investors will still be able to buy, sell, and trade them on exchanges. The main difference is that businesses that use cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology may now be subject to more regulation.

For businesses that use cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology, the classification of cryptocurrencies as commodities or securities will likely have a significant impact. Businesses that deal in securities must comply with certain regulations, such as registering with the SEC. Businesses that deal in commodities must comply with different regulations, such as registering with the CFTC. It is not clear yet which regulator will oversee cryptocurrencies, but businesses that use them should be prepared to comply with both securities and commodity regulations.

So, what do you think? Should cryptocurrencies be classified as securities or commodities? 

About Jacques Potts

Jacques is Sr. Marketing Manager at Ledgible and an experienced financial author, marketer, and crypto expert. His work has been featured on The Street, Project Serum, FirstTrade, and Investr.

Stay up to date

gdf-logoABC Logo
SOC 1 & SOC 2 Audited
chevron-left-circlechevron-right-circle linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram